I'm actually in favour of a DKP system.. I've seen both the officer loot rules and DKP systems. Though DKP systems all have their shortcomings and you kinda gotta try them all on until one type of DKP system works.
Community (officer) loot ALWAYS ends up that the people that can brown nose the best or are popular (favoritism happens) get loot before others that actually NEED.. and there is FAR less transparency between officers and guild/legion members.
For each item given out Officers would have to explain and justify every choice. And screw up once or forget someone... and the shit hits the fan rather quickly.
__________________
|